Surfshark
88
Private Internet Access (PIA)
82| Surfshark | Private Internet Access (PIA) | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $2.19/month | $2.03/month |
| Platforms | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS |
| privacy | 86 | 80 |
| speed | 88 | 80 |
| security | 89 | 85 |
| features | 90 | 88 |
| value | 94 | 90 |
| usability | 89 | 76 |
Our Verdict
This is a competitive comparison. Surfshark takes the lead with an overall score of 88/100 versus Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 82/100. The biggest difference between the two is in usability, where Surfshark scores 89 compared to Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 76. Choose Surfshark if you prioritise budget-conscious users wanting premium vpn features at a low price — it excels for users who value unlimited simultaneous connections on a single subscription. Choose Private Internet Access (PIA) if technical users who value open-source software and configuration flexibility matters more to you, particularly if you want largest server network in the industry with 35,000+ servers across 91 countries. Both tools are strong choices, but your decision should come down to which feature set aligns with your priorities and budget.
Surfshark
A budget-friendly VPN with unlimited simultaneous connections, strong privacy features, and a growing server network, now part of the Nord Security family.
Full review →Private Internet Access (PIA)
A veteran VPN provider with the largest server network in the industry, open-source applications, and a proven no-logs policy tested in court, now owned by Kape Technologies.
Full review →Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Surfshark or Private Internet Access (PIA)?
Surfshark scores 88/100 compared to Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 82/100 in our review. However, the best choice depends on your requirements — Surfshark is best for budget-conscious users wanting premium vpn features at a low price, whilst Private Internet Access (PIA) is best for technical users who value open-source software and configuration flexibility.
Is Surfshark free?
Surfshark starts at $2.19/month. Private Internet Access (PIA) starts at $2.03/month.
Which VPN is more secure?
Both Surfshark and Private Internet Access (PIA) offer strong security. Surfshark scores 89 for security, whilst Private Internet Access (PIA) scores 85. See our full reviews for detailed security analysis.
Can I switch from Surfshark to Private Internet Access (PIA)?
Yes. Most VPNs make it straightforward to switch. Cancel your existing subscription, export any saved data if applicable, and sign up with the new provider. We recommend running both simultaneously for a brief overlap period to ensure a smooth transition.
Other Comparisons
See how these tools stack up against other options.
